崔剿†ï¼Žæ˜¯ä¸ç”¢é‚„是新的å°å»º
來æºï¼šlink
ã€æ˜Žå ±å°ˆè¨Šã€‘作者為香港教育å¸é™¢å°ˆä»»å°Žå¸«
「所有經濟å¸å®¶æœ€å¤§çš„è¬¬èª¤èŽ«éŽæ–¼æŠŠè‡ªç”±å’Œè‡ªç”±ç«¶çˆæ··ç‚ºä¸€è«‡ã€‚ã€
Frank Knight (1935)《競çˆçš„倫ç†ã€‹
這種最大的謬誤是香港ä¸ç”¢éšŽç´šçš„æ ¸å¿ƒåƒ¹å€¼ï¼Œèªç‚ºè‡ªç”±ç¶“æ¿Ÿèƒ½è‡ªå‹•åœ°å¯¦ç¾æœ€å¤§çš„自由。
â—經濟層é¢ï¸°ä¸ç’°æ ¸å¿ƒåƒ¹å€¼ä»£è¡¨
Alice Poon (2006)在近作Land and the Ruling Class in Hong Kong指香港ä¸ç”¢éšŽç´šæ ¹æœ¬ä¸æ˜¯ä¸ç”¢éšŽç´šã€‚åœ¨è¿‘ä¹Žææ´²ä¸ä¸–ç´€å°å»ºæ¨¡å¼çš„ç¶“æ¿Ÿä¸‹ï¼Œé¦™æ¸¯äººèŠ±äº†å…æˆä»¥ä¸Šçš„é‡‘éŒ¢æŠ•å…¥æ–¼ä¸æˆæ¯”例地高昂的樓房ã€å…¬å…±æœå‹™ã€‚é‚„è¦å‘½çš„æ˜¯é›–ç„¶å¯å‹•用的收入少之åˆå°‘,但香港人ä¸ä½†ä¸æœƒæ‡·ç–‘自身的處境,還繼續自我感覺良好。
å› ç‚ºé¦™æ¸¯ä¸ç”¢éšŽç´šç›¸ä¿¡å‹¤å¥®å¿…然會æˆåŠŸï¼Œè²§çª®å¿…ç„¶æ˜¯æ‡¶æƒ°çš„çµæžœã€‚ç›¸ä¿¡å¯ŒåŒæƒ…心的ä¿å®ˆä¸»ç¾©ï¼Œé¦™æ¸¯ä¸ç”¢æ˜¯å–¬æ²»å¸ƒæ®Šæ‰€æŽ¨å´‡çš„compassionate conservative的信徒。經濟政ç–上,相信低稅率ã€ä½Žç¦åˆ©ï¼Œä½•苦è¦äº¤å¤šäº›ç¨…æ›å–ç¦åˆ©ï¼ŒåˆæŠ•訴政府無照顧ä¸ç”¢éšŽç´šã€‚ç¦åˆ©åœ‹å®¶æ˜¯é€™éšŽå±¤åŠå¹´ä»£é¸æ°‘çš„ç¥¨æˆ¿æ¯’è—¥ï¼Œã€Œè‡ªé£Ÿå…¶åŠ›ã€æ˜¯ç¾ä»£ä¿å®ˆä¸»ç¾©çš„åŸºæœ¬è«–è¿°ã€‚æ–¼æ˜¯é«˜åœ°åƒ¹å°æ–¼æœ‰æ¨“人士是雙刃åŠï¼Œé›–ç„¶è¦æ±ä¾›è²´æ¨“ï¼Œä½†å€‹å€‹åœ¨éŠ€è¡Œåæ“éŽç™¾è¬ã€Œè³‡ç”¢ã€ï¼Œä¸ç”¢éšŽç´šè‡ªæˆ‘感覺良好。
â—æ–‡åŒ–層é¢ï¸°è³‡æœ¬ä¸»ç¾©éœ¸æ¬Šè«–è¿°
è¦è§£é‡‹ç‚ºä»€éº¼é¦™æ¸¯ã€Œä¸ç”¢ã€è‡ªæˆ‘æ„Ÿè¦ºè‰¯å¥½ï¹–ç‚ºä»€éº¼è€æ˜¯ä¸è¦ºå¾—é大地產商å‰å‰Šï¹–1930年代的æ„大利哲å¸å®¶Antonio Gramsciæä¾›äº†ç”案。他指當時的政府和教會壟斷了æ„è˜å½¢æ…‹çš„æ¼”繹,é€éŽæ½›ç§»é»˜åŒ–的社會化,æ„大利å—部的農民自我感覺良好,完全ä¸è‡ªè¦ºå—到æ„大利北部工æ¥å®¶éšŽå±¤çš„å‰å‰Šã€‚在ç¾ä»£ï¼ŒJohn Perkins (2004)在Confessions of an Economic Hit Manä¸æå¯«äº†æš—ä¸ç‚ºç¾Žåœ‹æœå‹™çš„ç¶“æ¿Ÿè·æ¥æ®ºæ‰‹åœ¨åœ‹éš›é¡§å•å…¬å¸çš„æŽ©é£¾ä¸‹ï¼Œç”¨å¤§é‡çš„錢把發展ä¸åœ‹å®¶çš„æ”¿åºœæ‹‰åˆ°ç‚ºç¾Žåœ‹ç¶“濟æœå‹™çš„大陰謀ä¸ï¼Œä½¿ä»–們在經濟上å—åˆ°æŽ§åˆ¶ã€æ”¿æ²»ä¸Šç‚ºç¾Žåœ‹æœå‹™ã€‚é€éŽä¸–銀ã€åœ‹åŸºæœƒçš„貸款,美國å‘這些國家æä¾›é€æ”¯å’Œè²¸æ¬¾ã€‚è²¸å‡ºçš„éŒ¢ï¼Œæœ€å¾Œç”±ç¾Žåœ‹ä¼æ¥ä¾†åŒ…辦,錢從美國的左袋入å³è¢‹ã€‚在Alice Poonçš„æè¿°ä¸ï¼Œæˆ‘們亦有如æ¤çš„å…‰æ™¯ï¼Œç‚ºå¹¾å¤§å®¶æ—æˆ–å…¶å公叿‰“工,å‘éŠ€è¡Œè²¸æ¬¾è²·æ¨“ï¼Œæ¯æœˆäº¦å‘這幾個大家æ—的地產商åŠå…¶æŽ§åˆ¶çš„公共æœå‹™é‚€ç¨…,ä¸ç”¢å®šç¾©ä¸å¿…ä¸å¯å°‘的經濟自由(economic independenceï¼‰åªæ˜¯é¡èŠ±æ°´æœˆã€‚
â—æœ¬åœ°ç¶“æ¿Ÿè·æ¥æ®ºæ‰‹
ä¸éŽåœ¨æœ¬åœ°ä¸€çœ¾ç¶“æ¿Ÿè·æ¥æ®ºæ‰‹é¼“å¹ã€Œç¶“æ¿Ÿè‡ªç”±ç‰æ–¼å€‹äººè‡ªç”±ã€ä¸‹ï¼Œå†åŠ ä¸Šæ¶ˆè²»ä¸»ç¾©çš„è«–è¿°éœ¸æ¬Šï¼Œé¦™æ¸¯ä¸ç”¢æ˜¯ä¸€çåæ“éŽç™¾è¬ã€Œè³‡ç”¢ã€ã€ä¸€ä¸Šé£›æ©Ÿã€Œæ”žã€ä¸‰ä»½ä¸æ–‡å…©ä»½è‹±æ–‡å ±ç´™ã€é£›æ©Ÿæœªåœå¥½ç«‹å³é–‹æ‰‹æ©Ÿæ›°ã€Œå–‚,返到嚟喇﹗ã€çš„人士。在消費主義的強大宣傳下,我們ä¸å–®ä¸æœƒåæ€è‡ªå·±ç¶“濟倚賴(economic dependence)的程度,å»éŽç€çœŸæ£æ„義的ä¸ç”¢éšŽç´šç”Ÿæ´»ï¼Œå„åœ°çš„æ¶ˆè²»æƒ…å ±ï¼Œæ‰€è¬‚ä¸ç”¢å¯ä»¥å¦‚數家ç背誦如æµï¼Œæ‡‚去倫敦Burberryç‰¹è³£å ´ï¹”å»æ°¸é æžä¸æ¸…æ¹–å—æ˜¯å“ªå€‹æ¹–çš„å—é¢ã€æ²³åŒ—æ˜¯å“ªæ¢æ²³çš„北é¢ï¼Œæ˜¯å¦æ”¯æŒç¾Žåœ‹æ”»æ‰“伊拉克,亦會啞å£ç„¡è¨€ï¹”文化上永é 缺ä¹ä¸ç”¢çš„å…§æ¶µã€‚å› ç‚ºåœ¨é€™å€‹æ–‡åŒ–éœ¸æ¬Šä¸‹ï¼Œæœ¬åœ°ç¶“æ¿Ÿè·æ¥æ®ºæ‰‹å‘Šè¨´ä½ å€‘ä½ èº«åœ¨comfort zone,å¯ä»¥åœ¨é•·å‡æœŸæ™‚往曼谷åšSpaã€åˆ°æ—¥æœ¬æœè–購物。周末到羅湖商æ¥åŸŽï¼Œå°ç€å¾žå››å·ä¾†çš„æŒ‰æ‘©å¸«è¶¾é«˜æ°£æšã€‚é¢å°èº«é‚Šçš„外來民工,「ä¸ç”¢ã€çš„自我感覺實在良好,永é ä¸ç›¸ä¿¡å°å»ºæ™‚代的農奴階層ä»ç„¶å˜åœ¨æ–¼ç¾ä»£çš„香港。
æ£å¦‚é™³å† ä¸(2005)在《我這一代香港人——æˆå°±èˆ‡å¤±èª¤ã€‹ï¼Œä»–那一代「……以為自己有多厲害ã€å¤šéˆæ´»ã€å¤šæœ‰æ‰è¯ã€ï¼ˆé 7),他們在「出é“çš„1970å’Œ1980年代,在經濟上嘗到甜é ……還以為自己見多è˜å»£ã€ï¼ˆé 7)。果然真是見多è˜å»£ï¹—
建è°åƒé–±ï¼šseechuen.com [å‰ªå ±] 和諧社會備忘
我的ä¸é«˜ç”¢ä¸Šå¸å€‘,都喜æ¡å•我ä¸åœ‹å››æ›¸äº”經諸å百家於社會有何用。åˆèªç‚ºå¸è¡“應留在å¸é™¢è£ã€‚ä»–å€‘éƒ½æ˜¯å–„è‰¯çš„äººï¼Œå¯æ˜¯å°ç¤¾æœƒæ™‚事的關心,åªé™æ–¼é‚£äº›éŽä¸€å…©å¤©å¾Œä»ç‚ºäººå»£ç‚ºè«‡è«–的大事,關心的角度,首先為與自身的關係,二為作八掛新èžèˆ¬çœ‹ã€‚ä»–å€‘éƒ½æ˜¯æ¥µä¹‹è°æ˜Žèƒ½å¹¹çš„人,但如數家ç的,確是高級é¤å»³ã€åº¦å‡é»žå之類。
éžå¸¸çš„累呢。起床了沒有?想到明天也得上ç,委屈得想å“。煙大å£å¤§å£çš„æŠ½è‘—,åŒäº‹å»çšºè‘—çœ‰ã€‚æˆ‘å¾—èº²èµ·ä¾†æŠ½ç…™ï¼Œä¸æƒ³è®“我æˆäº†å‰å‰Šè€…之一,至少我è¦é‚„äººå®¶ä¸€å€‹ä¸æœƒå·®ä¸ŠåŠ å·®çš„å·¥ä½œç’°å¢ƒã€‚æ²’æœ‰ä»»ä½•æ–¹æ³•å¯ä»¥ä»¤è‡ªå·±å¥½å—一點。尤其在這樣的星期天,尤其在他人連放四日我å»å‘†è‘—åªæœ‰ä¸€å¤©å‡çš„æ™‚å€™ã€‚æƒ³ä¿æŒå¥½å¿ƒåœ°é€™æ¨£é›£ã€‚
茵,我也é‡éŽé€™æ¨£çš„上å¸ï¼Œä¸çŸ¥é“說些什麼æ‰å¥½ã€‚
閃,我後來也病了,看了醫生,明天è¦ä¸Šçäº†ã€‚ä½ é‚„æ˜¯å¾ˆç´¯å—Žï¼Ÿé€™å¹¾å¤©å¯ä¸å¯ä»¥æ—©ä¸€é»žä¸‹ç?
我好一些了,ç¡äº†æ•´å¤©ï¼Œå–‰åš¨çš„痛開始減輕。今天晚上如果趕得åŠï¼Œæƒ³åœ¨9點去上瑜çˆç,å†å›žä¾†æ—ºè§’è·Ÿä½ å•†é‡äº›äº‹æƒ…ã€‚ä½ ç”šéº¼æ™‚å€™ä¸‹çï¼Ÿæˆ‘æ”¶å·¥æ™‚å†æ‰“çµ¦ä½ ã€‚
i randomly search for some website and read your reflective essay.
middle class , grass root, management class, upper class…….they are all the terms derived by the so called scholars.
somehow when you are thinking an issue or current issue deeply, you will find that you have been being cheated by those terms.
who are you? when will you go? where is your soul? we have to ask ourselves.
i agree to those points that middle class in hk is really being in the middle and they are the by-product of a ever changing soceity.
i am a teacher and i never think that i should afford the loan of buying an apartment.
your home is not the place you put your soul in … we can find a better places.
thanks …mates
dave, i must clarify that the essay is quoted from an author called 崔剿†, i think it’s a good piece of reference but i dare not to be mistaken as the author. thanks for your sharing.
第一次在æ¤ç•™è¨€ ^_^
é›–ç„¶ä¸ä¸€å®š. 但事實上. 物質與文化總是å°ç«‹çš„.
都是幾悲哀的ç¾è±¡